Paul H. Carr, Ph. D., debated with Prof Laurence I. Gould on Saturday, Nov 19. 2011 at the New England Section of the American Physical Society Meeting at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst.


   Dr. Carr's PowerPoint talk was entitled, Data Supporting Anthropogenic Global Warming: Balancing Economics and Ecology  It is available on his web page (It might take 15 seconds to download.)


   Prof Laurence I. Gould' talk was Anthropogenic “Global Warming” —

Illuminating some of its Scientific and Methodological Flaws. His web page includes "GOULD PRESENTATION,"  is almost the same PowerPoint he used for the debate.




 -Correlation of carbon dioxide, C02, and temperature increases since the beginning of the industrial era.


-Carbon dioxide increase is from burning fossil fuels (Carbon Dating).


-Increased greenhouse gases (C02) blanket and warm the earth’s surface, allowing less heat to reach the stratosphere, which is cooling.


-Solar irradiance has not increased since 1940 (sunspot cycles).


-Present CO2 level of 390 ppm is 31% higher than in the last 800,000yrs.

-       Extrapolates to 900 ppm by 2100.


 -When CO2 was 900 ppm, 51 Million years ago, earth was ice-free, sea levels 100s of feet higher.


 -Present sea levels are projected to increase 2.5 – 6 ft by 2100.


- Without the radiative forcing of noncondensing CO2, the terrestrial greenhouse would collapse, plunging the global climate into an icebound earth state


Dr. Carr's talk references included:

(1) Atmospheric CO2: Principal Control Knob Governing Earth’s Temperature;

Andrew A. Lacis Science330, 356-359, 15 October 2010

(2) Reconciling Anthropogenic Climate Change with Observed Temperature 1998–2008.  Robert K. Kaufmann et al. Proc. National Academy of Sciences 2011


Prof Gould's talk references included:

(1) Taken by Storm: The Troubled Science, Policy, and Politics of Global Warming

Christopher Essex & McKitrick, Key Porter Books (2008).

(2) Heaven and Earth: Global Warming, the Missing Science 

Ian Plimer, Taylor Trade Publishing (2009).